Andrea Andrews Compass Rose Realty: Transforming Struggles into Success in Real Estate
Most agents enter real estate with a license in hand and no roadmap to follow. They show up at their new brokerage ready to work, and all they get is a "good luck" and a pat on the shoulder. No training. No systems. No mentor. And within two years, a huge percentage of them are gone.
If that sounds familiar, this episode of Why Do I Suck As A Real Estate Agent is one you need to watch. I sat down with Andrea Andrews, Principal Broker and Owner of Compass Rose Realty LLC out of Jonesboro, Arkansas real estate broker territory, and she broke down exactly how she went from getting a pat on the shoulder as a new agent to leading a 50+ agent brokerage that has been voted Best of NEA Brokerage five years running.
Andrea Andrews Compass Rose Realty - Principal Broker Jonesboro AR
Before we get into the tactics, here is who you are learning from.
Andrea Andrews is the Principal Broker and Owner of Compass Rose Realty LLC, a Northeast Arkansas real estate brokerage based in Jonesboro, Arkansas. She leads 50+ agents across Northeast and Central Arkansas, and her track record speaks for itself:
| Achievement | Details |
|---|---|
| Triple Diamond Producer | 2020, 2021, 2022 |
| Best of NEA Brokerage | 2022, 2023 |
| Certifications |
MRP PSA RENE RSPS SRS |
| Specialties |
First-time buyers Luxury properties Military Recreation & Vacation Relocation |
What makes Andrea different is not just the accolades. It is the systems, the mentorship model, and the relentless preparation behind every transaction. All of that starts from a very honest place - she almost failed like everyone else.
Why Most Real Estate Agents Fail In Their First Two Years
The "Good Luck, Kiddo" Problem
Roughly 75% of newly licensed real estate agents quit within their first year, and around 87% leave the business within five years.
Here is the honest truth about why most real estate agents fail: they pass the test, they walk in the door, and nobody is waiting to help them. That is exactly what happened to Andrea.
“I think why a lot of people suck as a real estate agent is because they join, they take their test, and they pass it. And then it’s like, okay, now what? I walked into the brokerage because I had a friend there and I didn’t interview anywhere else. I said, ‘I passed. I’m here.’ And they said, ‘Good luck, kiddo,’ and just gave me a pat on the shoulder. There was really no training at all. So you’re just on your own when you first get into real estate.”
The issue is not motivation. Most new agents are hungry. The issue is structure. Without a system, without a mentor, and without clear daily actions, even the most driven agents drift. They do not know what to do next, so they do nothing productive - or worse, they sit in the office playing solitaire while their pipeline runs dry.
If you are reading this and that sounds like your current situation, keep going. The next section is the turning point.
How to Survive Your First 2 Years in Real Estate: The R&D Phase
Treat Year One Like Investment, Not Income
Andrea did not close a ton of deals in her first two years.
What she did was treat that time like a research and development phase - and that reframe changed everything.
“I called those first two years in real estate my research and development phase. I didn’t sell a lot, but I was reading everything I could get my hands on. I was listening to podcasts. I cut out any distractions that weren’t attributing toward my goals. Anytime I got a seasoned agent on the phone, I was asking them questions like, ‘What books do I read? What would you tell yourself as a new agent?’ I tried everything they said to do until I found what worked for me.”
If you are in year one right now and your commission checks are small, stop measuring your success by closings only. Start measuring it by capacity.
That slow start is more common than most new agents realize. According to the National Association of Realtors:
Agents with two years or less of experience earn a median income of about $8,100,
While those with 16 or more years in the industry earn around $78,900 annually.
The gap highlights how much of the early years are about building skills, knowledge, and momentum.
Here are the behaviors that Andrea leaned on hard in those early years:
Reading every book she could find on sales, mindset, and real estate strategy
Listening to podcasts - yes, like this one - to absorb from working agents
Cutting distractions that were not moving her toward her goals
Calling seasoned agents and asking the right questions
Testing what she learned until she found what actually worked for her
Her top book recommendations for new agents to start with:
The Compound Effect
The One Thing
Shift
Think and Grow Rich
The Millionaire Real Estate Agent
The R&D mindset is the bridge between surviving and thriving. Once you have the foundation, what you build on it becomes unstoppable - starting with your daily habits and prospecting.
Mindset Shift - Treat It Like A Business
Stop Waiting. Start Calling.
One of the clearest signs that an agent is going to make it is this: they do not wait for business to come to them. They go get it. Andrea describes this with zero ambiguity.
“You just gotta show up every day and work your heart out. I would say, I’m not leaving today until I get a listing. And I would call and call until I got one. It didn’t matter how many calls it took. My first cold call I ever did, I got three listings out of it. But then I might go in for a day and it may take a hundred calls to get one.”
This is the contrast that separates the agents who build careers from the ones who give up. Andrea walked into that same brokerage where her colleagues were passing time with card games. While they waited, she called. While they played solitaire, she was dialing for listings.
The Three Things That Predict Success
Andrea boils it down to three traits she looks for in any new agent she takes on. If you can hold these for your first year - or two years - you are going to make it:
Patience - the market rewards those who stay in the game
Consistency - small actions compounded over time equal massive results
Curiosity - always asking, always learning, never assuming you know enough
Cold calling for real estate agents is not glamorous. But the discipline of picking up the phone every single day is what builds the pipeline that funds everything else. Get comfortable with the number game - and remember, even a hundred calls for one listing is a profitable use of your day.
The Super Seller 17 Listing System
From Unprepared to Unstoppable
Andrea's first listing appointment is a story every agent needs to hear. She drove an hour to a $30,000 listing with a contract in her hand, no prep, and no presentation. When she sat down, she told the sellers straight out: "I don't know what I'm doing. This is my first time."
She did not close it. But she got through the whole process - the price drops, the open houses, the rejection - and that experience taught her more than she ever expected. It also planted the seed for what would become her entire listing presentation strategy.
“Now we go in with the Super Seller 17. We come in with our one-pager of credentials - that’s our resume, it’s like why you should work with us instead of someone else. Then I have a second page with all the certifications and what they mean to the seller. We come in with the NAR report, the seller net sheet at multiple price points - low list, adjusted list, high list in 5% increments - a photo shoot checklist, tax records. Anything you can possibly imagine. It takes me two hours to prep for any listing I do, no matter how big or how small.”
Here are 7 items from Andrea’s ‘Super Seller 17’ listing presentation system:
| Item | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Agent credentials one-pager | Why the seller should choose you over anyone else |
| Certifications page | What your designations mean for the seller’s transaction |
| NAR report | Market credibility backed by national data |
| Five sets of comps | Multiple pricing perspectives to anchor the conversation |
| Seller net sheet (multiple price points) | Low list, adjusted list, high list - in 5% increments |
| Photo shoot checklist | Set seller expectations before the shoot |
| Tax records | Ground the pricing in verifiable public data |
When a banker called Andrea and confidently told her he thought his house was worth $800,000, she came back with comps that put it closer to $550,000. Because she had the data, she could walk him through it calmly and let the numbers do the talking. That is what preparation buys you: the ability to handle the hard conversations without flinching.
The agents who lose listings are not usually the least experienced. They are the least prepared. If you build your own version of the Super Seller 17, you will win more rooms than you ever expected - and that momentum naturally leads into how you grow and who you surround yourself with.
What Makes Compass Rose Realty LLC Different
Built-In Infrastructure So Agents Can Just Sell
When Andrea opened Compass Rose Realty LLC, she thought back on everything she had to do alone at her old brokerage - the photos, the marketing, the coordination. And used those lessons as the foundation for how to build a real estate brokerage that truly supports its agents.
“We have an in-house professional photographer and drone pilot. We have an office manager, a transaction coordinator, an MLS data coordinator, and a marketing director - all in-house. They work for our agents so they can be out doing the meat and potatoes: selling and closing.”
When an agent does not have to coordinate their own photos, write their own remarks, or manage their own MLS data, they free up hours every week to do what actually earns income: prospecting, showing, and closing.
This is what real estate mentorship programs should look like at a structural level:
Mentors assigned for first five transactions - with a 50/50 split to incentivize real guidance
Executive Broker growth path - build a team of 10 and earn 100% commissions
Monthly book club with essay incentive - top agent wins 5% bonus on next commission check
The Atlas - a 400-page playbook updated annually, covering contracts, open houses, lead gen, apps, and more
Online training system via the Train app for on-demand learning
The Atlas alone is worth examining because it functions as one of the most detailed real estate systems and playbooks for agents inside Compass Rose Realty. It is a living, breathing document - now in its sixth volume - where every agent contributes ideas to make it better each year. This is what separates a Northeast Arkansas real estate brokerage that retains talent from one that churns through it.
When your systems are this solid, maintaining your standards becomes the natural next step.
How To Stay Profitable In A Shifting Market
Reset Expectations. Then Punch Every Day.
The COVID market was not real life. Andrea says it plainly.
“The COVID years were not a normal market. I’d put a listing on and get ten offers over list, no contingencies, appraisal gap, and a love letter. That was probably a once-in-a-lifetime thing. Now we’re back to standard - 60 to 90 days on market depending on how it’s positioned. We just give sellers the expectation and then we punch it every day - ads, open houses, live videos. We do everything we can.”
Knowing how to stay profitable in a shifting market comes down to one thing: controlling what you can control. Here is Andrea's current game plan when listings slow down:
Set realistic expectations with sellers upfront - give them a data-backed day-on-market range
Run targeted paid ads across all social platforms for every active listing
Host open houses - Compass Rose runs about 10 every Sunday
Do live video walkthroughs - minimum 1,000 views per live according to Andrea
Send weekly view-to-save ratio reports to sellers to show the work being done
Consider a 5% price drop if market data supports it, rather than just waiting
The agent who fails in a slow market is the one who sits and waits. The agent who thrives is the one who out-hustles the market through sheer visibility. And keeping that hustle sustainable over the long haul requires protecting your energy - which is where burnout prevention becomes non-negotiable.
Real Estate Time Blocking Strategy: Avoiding Burnout
Schedule Your Life Before Your Work Fills It
Burnout in real estate is not about working too hard. It is about not protecting what matters. Andrea's approach is straightforward, and it comes directly from one of the first books she read as a new agent.
“Time blocking is so good. The One Thing was one of the first books I read in real estate. I always time block out time for my family, for myself to recharge. That’s so important. You just schedule the time in there.”
Here is a simple real estate time blocking strategy based on how Andrea structures her priorities:
| Time Block | What It Protects |
|---|---|
| Family time | Scheduled first, not filled in around work |
| Personal recharge | Travel, hobbies, brain breaks - non-negotiable |
| Prospecting hours | Dedicated calling blocks with no interruptions |
| Listing prep | 2+ hours per appointment minimum |
| Team/training time | Book club, mentoring, brokerage operations |
Andrea takes a 10-day trip with her kids every other summer. She visits Airbnbs in the Arkansas hill country on weekends to reset. She does not treat rest as a reward for finishing her work - she treats it as part of the work. Because an agent running on empty cannot serve their clients, their team, or their growth.
Block the time. Put it in the calendar first. Then build your work schedule around it.
Real Estate Mentorship Programs: Find The Right Mentor
This Is The Simplest Shortcut That Exists
After everything Andrea shared - the systems, the listings, the brokerage build - her closing advice was the most stripped-down and direct of the entire conversation.
“Find a great mentor. Find somebody that’s willing to take you under their wing and show you what they know, and listen to everything that they’re trying to teach you. If they’re successful and that’s what you’re striving to be, just find a great mentor and really listen and pay attention and you’ll get there.”
Keep the Conversation Going:
Reach out to Andrea Andrews:
And if you are in Northeast or Central Arkansas and want access to all of this - the systems, the mentorship, the infrastructure - reach out to Andrea Andrews:
Website → compassroserealtyllc.com
Facebook → https://www.facebook.com/andreaandrewscompassroserealtyllc
LinkedIn → https://www.linkedin.com/in/andreaandrewsrealtor/
Or call her at (870) 761-7774.
Follow Monte Reyment:
And if you want to learn how to take action and build a real estate business that actually moves, follow Monte Reyment and stay connected with his latest insights.
Website → https://www.tarealtygroup.com/
Facebook → https://www.facebook.com/montereygb/
Instagram → https://www.instagram.com/montereyment/
LinkedIn → https://www.linkedin.com/company/takeactionrealtygroup
Frequently Asked Questions
Who Is Andrea Andrews?
Andrea Andrews is the Principal Broker and Owner of Compass Rose Realty LLC, a Northeast Arkansas real estate brokerage based in Jonesboro, Arkansas. She is a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider real estate professional, a multi-year Triple Diamond Producer, and has led her brokerage to five consecutive Best of NEA Brokerage awards.
What Is Compass Rose Realty?
Compass Rose Realty LLC is a Jonesboro Arkansas real estate broker firm with 50+ agents covering Northeast and Central Arkansas. It is known for its in-house support infrastructure, agent mentorship model, and The Atlas - a 400-page annual playbook for agents.
Why Do Most New Real Estate Agents Fail?
According to Andrea, why most real estate agents fail comes down to a lack of structure, mentorship, and daily outbound activity. Most agents get their license, walk into a brokerage with no training, and give up when they do not see quick results.
What Is The Super Seller 17 System?
The Super Seller 17 is Andrea Andrews Compass Rose Realty's 17-point listing presentation system. It includes credentials, NAR reports, five sets of comps, seller net sheets at multiple price points, photo checklists, and tax records. Andrea spends a minimum of two hours preparing for every listing appointment.
How Can I Win More Listing Appointments?
Invest in preparation. Build your own listing presentation system similar to the Super Seller 17. Come in with data, not opinions. Show sellers you have done the homework before you walk through the door. That is the foundation of a strong listing presentation strategy.
How Do You Stay Profitable In A Slow Market?
Control what you can control. Run ads, hold open houses, do live video tours, send weekly view-to-save ratio reports to sellers, and reset pricing expectations with data. Waiting is not a strategy. This is the core of Andrea's approach to how to stay profitable in a shifting market.
Should I Join A Mentorship-Based Brokerage?
If you are a new agent, the answer is almost always yes. Structured real estate mentorship programs give you systems, ride-along experience, and accountability that solo trial-and-error simply cannot replicate in the same timeframe.
What Books Should New Realtors Read?
Andrea recommends The Compound Effect, The One Thing, Shift, Think and Grow Rich, and The Millionaire Real Estate Agent as a starting point. Many of these are directly tied to her how to succeed as a new real estate agent philosophy.
How Do You Prevent Burnout In Real Estate?
Use real estate time blocking strategy. Schedule family time and personal recharge time first. Then fill in your work blocks. Protect your energy the same way you protect your pipeline - intentionally and consistently.
This podcast is produced by the Icons of Real Estate - #1 Real Estate Podcast Network.
Apply To Be A Guest On The Why Do I Suck As A Real Estate Agent Podcast
If you serve the real estate industry - through staffing, lending, brokerage, technology, or advisory - and you help agents grow smarter, not harder, we want to hear from you. Let's spotlight your insights.
